version control


When I discussed VersionControlTools I said that it was an unscientific agglomeration of opinion. As I was doing it I realized that I could add some spurious but mesmerizing numbers to my analysis by doing a survey. Google's spreadsheet makes the mechanics of conducting a survey really simple, so I couldn't resist.

I conducted the survey from February 23 2010 until March 3 2010 on the ThoughtWorks software development mailing list. I got 99 replies. In the survey I asked everyone to rate a number of version control tools using the following options:

The results were this:

ToolBestOKProblematicDangerousNo OpinionActive ResponsesApproval %

As well as the raw summary values, I've added two calculated columns here to help summarize the results.

The graph shows a scatter plot of approval percentage and active responses. As you can see there's a clear cluster around Subversion, git, and Mercurial with high approval and a large amount of responses. It's also clear that there's a big divide in approval between those three, together with Bazaar and Perforce, versus the rest.

Although the graph captures the headline information well, there's a couple of other subtleties I should mention.

Some caveats. This is a survey of opinion of ThoughtWorkers who follow our internal software development discussion list, nothing more. It's possible some of them may have been biased by my previous article (although unlikely, since I've never managed to get my ThoughtBot opinion-control software to work reliably). Opinions of tools are often colored by processes that are more about the organization than the tool itself. But despite these, I think it's an interesting data point.

I should also stress the important point to take away from this isn't the comparison between those close in the numbers, eg comparing git and Mercurial or comparing TFS and ClearCase. Any survey like this has a certain amount of noise in it, and I suspect the noise here is greater than such a difference. The important point is the big approval gap between the leading tools (Subversion, git, and Mercurial) and the laggards - essentially the point in VersionControlTools.

if you found this article useful, please share it. I appreciate the feedback and encouragement

Find similar articles at the tag

version control